Walk-In Showers vs. Tub-Shower Combos: A Comprehensive Comparison

Making a Splash in Bathroom Design Choices

Ever stood at the crossroads of a major bathroom remodel, wondering whether a sleek, space-saving walk-in shower or a versatile, comforting tub-shower combo is the right path?

Are you puzzled over which option will shower your Ottawa, KS, home with the most value?

You’re about to embark on a journey through the maze of modern bathroom renovations, learning the ins and outs of walk-in showers versus tub-shower combos.

This guide promises to navigate you through the complexities of choosing the best bathing solution that harmonizes with your lifestyle, space, and aesthetic preferences.

By the end, you’ll not only be equipped to make an informed decision about your bathroom remodeling project, but also poised to elevate your home’s comfort and appeal to potential future buyers.

Choosing Between Walk-In Showers and Tub-Shower Combos

A walk-in shower with tile
A tub-shower combo with a niche

When it comes to refreshing your home with a bathroom makeover, the heart of the matter quickly becomes a choice between the sleek allure of walk-in showers and the versatile charm of tub-shower combos.

Each option brings its own set of advantages to the table, tailored to suit different lifestyles, space configurations, and personal preferences.

In fact, converting your bathtub to a walk-in shower is one of the key things you should consider before your bathroom renovation.

Let’s dive into the critical aspects that distinguish these two contenders, helping you navigate towards a choice that best showers your Ottawa home with functionality and style.

Space Considerations

Creating the illusion of more space or actually having it can influence your bathroom’s overall feel and functionality.

Here’s how each option measures up:

  • Walk-In Showers: Known for their sleek profile, walk-in showers can make even the smallest bathroom space appear larger. Without the need for bulky shower doors or curtains, they offer an unobstructed view of your entire bathroom, enhancing the sense of openness.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: While requiring more square footage, tub-shower combos deliver unmatched versatility. They’re ideal for families needing both the quick convenience of a shower and the relaxing option of a bath in one unit. Installation of a tub-shower combo may necessitate moving walls or plumbing fixtures to accommodate the bathtub, affecting the project’s scope and cost.


Ease of access is a paramount concern for many, particularly those planning for the future with aging-in-place design principles (also known as universal design).

  • Walk-In Showers: With minimal to no step-up, walk-in showers are a boon for accessibility. Options like built-in benches, grab bars, and non-slip shower bases enhance safety and comfort, making showering a breeze for everyone.

  • Tub-Shower Combo: While not as accessible as walk-in showers, tub-shower combos offer a versatile bathing option. For those with less severe mobility issues, adding grab bars and a non-slip mat can improve safety, making these combos a more flexible choice for families with varying needs.

Resale Potential

Your bathroom renovation can impact your home’s appeal to future buyers, making the choice between a walk-in shower and a tub-shower combo a strategic one.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: A safe bet for resale, these tub-shower units cater to a broader audience by accommodating preferences for both quick showers and leisurely baths, particularly appealing to families with young children or pets.

  • Walk-In Showers: Often viewed as a luxurious addition to a modern bathroom, walk-in showers can significantly enhance the appeal of your home to potential buyers looking for updated, accessible features. Their sleek design and ease of use may attract a demographic focused on style and convenience, potentially increasing your home’s resale value in the competitive market.

Usage Preferences

Reflecting on who primarily uses the bathroom and how they prefer to do so can guide your decision:

  • Primary Bathrooms: For those who cherish their occasional soaks but mostly rely on showers for daily routines, a tub-shower combo offers the best of both worlds. However, a bathroom with both a freestanding tub and a walk-in shower is the best option for a primary bathroom if you have the space.

  • Guest Bathrooms: Aim for a walk-in shower here, prioritizing ease of use and cleaning over the infrequent luxury of a bath.

By considering these aspects, you can better envision which bathroom update—whether it’s installing a state-of-the-art walk-in shower or opting for the classic functionality of a tub-shower combo—will most suitably refresh your sanctuary and align with your lifestyle in Ottawa, KS.

Pros and Cons: Navigating Your Choices


Every renovation decision comes with its list of advantages and drawbacks, and the choice between walk-in showers and tub-shower combos is no exception.

Understanding the upsides and potential pitfalls of each option will ensure your new bathroom suits your lifestyle while also considering future resale value.

Pros of Walk-In Showers

Walk-in showers offer a range of benefits that make them a popular choice for modern bathroom remodels:

  • Accessibility: With their low threshold, walk-in showers are easily accessible, reducing the risk of trips and falls.

  • Space Efficiency: Their sleek design can make even the smallest bathroom appear more spacious.

  • Customization: From multi-functional shower heads to luxurious body sprays, the options to tailor your showering experience are nearly endless.

  • Aesthetic Appeal: Walk-in showers can act as a centerpiece in your bathroom, contributing to a clean, modern look.

Cons of Walk-In Showers

Despite their benefits, walk-in showers might not be the perfect fit for every household:

  • Lack of Versatility: Homes with only one bathroom might benefit from keeping a tub for families with small children or pets.

  • Resale Considerations: Potential buyers with young families often look for bathtubs in the primary bathroom.

Pros of Tub-Shower Combos

Tub-shower combos are an excellent option for those looking for flexibility and comfort in their bathing routines:

  • Dual Functionality: Offers the convenience of a quick shower or the luxury of a long bath in the same space.

  • Family-Friendly: Ideal for households with children, providing a convenient option for bath time.

  • Resale Value: Appeals to a broader range of buyers, making it a safe choice for future saleability.

Cons of Tub-Shower Combos

However, tub-shower combos come with their own set of limitations:

  • Space Requirements: They can take up more room, which might not be ideal for smaller bathrooms.

  • Accessibility Issues: Climbing in and out of the tub can be challenging for those with mobility problems.

By weighing these pros and cons, residents of Ottawa, KS, can make a more informed decision on whether a walk-in shower or a tub-shower combo is the right choice for their home renovation project.

Remember, the best choice is the one that aligns with your current needs, lifestyle preferences, and future plans.

Cost and Installation: Budgeting Your Bathroom Update

Embarking on a bathroom renovation project brings financial considerations to the forefront, especially when deciding between the installation of a walk-in shower or a tub-shower combo.

Let’s break down the cost implications and installation factors for Ottawa, KS, residents planning their bathroom remodels.

Walk-In Showers: A Financial Overview

Opting for a walk-in shower can influence your budget in several ways:

  • Initial Costs: The price range for walk-in showers varies widely, influenced by choices in shower doors, shower heads, tiles, and additional features like body sprays and steam functions. Depending on your material selections and other features, a new shower installation could cost you anywhere from $6,500 to over $19,000.

  • Customization Costs: Custom features, including frameless glass doors, luxury showerheads, and elaborate tile work, can significantly increase the cost.

  • Installation Considerations: Labor costs for installing walk-in showers may be higher due to the complexity of work, especially if significant modifications to plumbing or walls are required.

Tub-Shower Combos: Budgeting for Versatility

The financial aspects of choosing a tub-shower combo include:

  • Affordability: Generally speaking, tub-shower combos are more budget-friendly, with costs varying based on the style of the bathtub, faucets, and showerhead options. Installing a tub-shower combo might cost between $4,500 and $9,000.

  • Installation Ease: Combos might involve less intricate plumbing work compared to custom walk-in showers, potentially leading to lower installation costs.

  • Resale Value Impact: Investing in a tub-shower combo could positively affect your home’s market appeal, possibly offering a better return on investment, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.

Navigating Installation Complexities

Regardless of which option you lean toward, consider these installation nuances:

  • Space Requirements: Measure your bathroom space to ensure your choice fits without necessitating extensive remodeling work.

  • Plumbing Adjustments: Both options might require plumbing changes. Walk-in showers could need new drain locations, while tub-shower combos might require adjustments to accommodate the tub.

  • Waterproofing: Proper waterproofing is crucial, especially for walk-in showers, to prevent leaks and water damage.

By carefully planning your budget and understanding the installation requirements of walk-in showers and tub-shower combos, you can make a cost-effective decision that enhances your bathroom’s functionality and aesthetics.

This foresight ensures your Ottawa, KS, home’s bathroom remodel meets your needs while aligning with your financial boundaries.

Space and Design: Crafting Your Ideal Bathroom

An Onyx shower installation

The layout and aesthetic appeal of your bathroom are significantly influenced by the choice between a walk-in shower and a tub-shower combo.

Let’s explore how each option can transform your bathroom space into a functional and stylish retreat.

Maximizing Bathroom Space

Efficient use of space is crucial, especially in smaller bathrooms.

Here’s how each option stacks up:

  • Walk-In Showers: Known for their sleek and minimalistic design, walk-in showers can free up floor space, making your bathroom appear larger and more open.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: While they take up more room, tub-shower combos are unbeatable in terms of versatility, offering both bathing and showering facilities in one compact unit.

Design Aesthetics

Creating a visually appealing bathroom that reflects your personal style is essential:

  • Walk-In Showers: Offer endless design possibilities, from frameless shower doors that create a seamless look to luxurious tiles and high-end shower heads for a custom showering experience.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: Allows for creativity with a variety of bathtub styles, shower curtains, and accessories to match any decor theme, from classic to contemporary. However, generally speaking, tub-shower combos are more in line with traditional vs. modern bathroom design.

Incorporating Modern Features

Both walk-in showers and tub-shower combos can be equipped with modern features to enhance your bathroom’s functionality and comfort:

  • Walk-in Showers: This can include built-in benches for added convenience, multiple showerheads for a spa-like experience, and even steam options for a relaxing escape. Here at Harshaw Home Renovators, we are proud to use Onyx shower systems for our walk-in shower installations. Follow the link to learn about the benefits of installing an Onyx shower system.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: Can be enhanced with whirlpool or air jets in bathtubs for a therapeutic bath, along with innovative faucets and adjustable showerheads for a tailored bathing experience.

By carefully considering how each option affects your bathroom’s space and design, you can create a sanctuary that not only meets your practical needs but also resonates with your aesthetic preferences.

Whether you’re leaning towards the sleek functionality of a walk-in shower or the cozy versatility of a tub-shower combo, your choice will set the tone for your bathroom’s new look and feel in your Ottawa, KS, home.

Water Usage and Environmental Considerations

Choosing between a walk-in shower and a tub-shower combo doesn’t just affect your daily routine; it also impacts your water usage and, consequently, your environmental footprint.

Let’s delve into how each option measures up in terms of efficiency and sustainability.

Conserving Water with Your Choice

  • Walk-In Showers: Typically, showers are more water-efficient than baths, especially when equipped with low-flow showerheads. A shorter shower can significantly reduce water usage, saving gallons of water with each use.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: Baths generally require more water, with a standard bathtub needing about 25 to 40 gallons for a single bath. Opting for a shower over a bath can lead to considerable water savings over time.

Enhancing Efficiency

Modern bathroom fixtures and accessories offer additional ways to conserve water, regardless of whether you choose a walk-in shower or a tub-shower combo:

  • Low-Flow Showerheads: Installing these in your shower can reduce water flow while still providing a satisfying showering experience, helping you save water and energy.

  • Shower Timers: Encourage shorter showers by using a timer, further reducing water and heating energy consumption.

  • Aerated Faucets: These mix air with water, delivering a gentle spray that uses less water for washing and rinsing.

Sustainable Practices

Adopting sustainable practices in your bathroom not only conserves water but also promotes a greener lifestyle:

  • Eco-Friendly Products: Using biodegradable soaps and shampoos reduces the amount of harmful chemicals that enter the water system.

  • Regular Maintenance: Keeping your plumbing fixtures, like showerheads and drains, in good working order prevents leaks and water wastage.

Making environmentally conscious choices in your bathroom remodel can lead to significant water savings, contributing to both lower utility bills and a reduced ecological footprint.

Whether you opt for the sleek functionality of a walk-in shower or the versatility of a tub-shower combo, incorporating water-saving features and practices can enhance the sustainability of your Ottawa, KS, home.

Long-Term Value and ROI: Making a Smart Investment

A premium bathroom remodeling project features luxurious finishes and high-end components

When updating your bathroom, considering the long-term value and potential return on investment (ROI) of your choices is crucial.

Whether you opt for a walk-in shower or a tub-shower combo, each option offers unique benefits that can affect your home’s appeal to future buyers in the Ottawa, KS, area.

Enhancing Home Value with Bathroom Updates

  • Walk-In Showers: These are often seen as a premium feature in modern homes, appealing to buyers looking for luxury and convenience. Their sleek design and ease of use can increase your home’s marketability and potential selling price.

  • Tub-Shower Combos: Ideal for families, a tub-shower combo can make your home more attractive to a broader range of buyers, especially those with young children or pets, potentially speeding up the sale process.

ROI Considerations

  • Cost vs. Value: While walk-in showers may require a higher initial investment, especially for high-end finishes and features like frameless shower doors or rainfall showerheads, they can also lead to a higher ROI due to their appeal in the current market. That being said, the ROI of a tub-shower combo vs. a walk-in shower will depend greatly on the preferences of the buyer, the availability of other bathrooms in your home, and the quality of the installation.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

  • Assess Your Needs: Consider how the choice of a walk-in shower or a tub-shower combo aligns with your current lifestyle and future plans. Think about what potential buyers in your area might be looking for.

  • Quality and Style: Investing in high-quality materials and timeless designs can enhance the appeal and longevity of your bathroom, ensuring that it remains attractive to buyers for years to come.

By carefully weighing the long-term value and potential ROI of your bathroom renovation choices, you can ensure that your investment not only suits your immediate needs but also contributes to the overall value of your Ottawa, KS, home.

Whether you choose the elegance of a walk-in shower or the practicality of a tub-shower combo, focusing on quality, style, and market trends will help you maximize your renovation’s impact on your home’s value.

Transform Your Bathroom Oasis with Harshaw Home Renovators

This guide has armed you with essential insights to navigate the decision between walk-in showers and tub-shower combos, ensuring your Ottawa, KS, home’s bathroom is not only a functional space but a personal retreat.

Harshaw Home Renovators specializes in turning your bathroom dreams into reality, blending style, efficiency, and value seamlessly.

Ready to take the next step in your home renovation journey?

Fill out our contact form today, or give us a call, and let Harshaw Home Renovators craft the perfect bathroom oasis for you.

More Posts